top of page

The Pros and Cons of Influencer Marketing for Brands

AJ Marketing - The Pros and Cons of Influencer Marketing for Brands

You've probably noticed a recent trend if you've spent even a smidge of time scrolling through your social media feeds lately. Yep, you guessed it—we're talking about influencer marketing. Those fitness gurus sharing their secret protein shake recipes, the fashionistas with a knack for picking the hottest trends before they even hit the runways, or the tech geeks unboxing the latest gadgets—all these are a part of a phenomenon that's impossible to ignore.

A staggering 22.6% of internet users aged between 16 to 64 confess to following influencers and other experts on social media. And, come on, who can blame them? It's like having a friend who is always in-the-know about everything you love, a friend who is ready to recommend products they've tried and loved, making your choices so much easier.

AJ Marketing - The Pros and Cons of Influencer Marketing for Brands - Types of Social Media Accounts Followed

But there's more to it than meets the eye, especially when it comes to the relationship between these influencers and the brands they endorse. That's what we're here to discuss today—the exciting, yet sometimes perplexing marketing marvel. In this article, we'll tackle both the pros and the cons of influencer marketing. Should your brand ride the influencer wave, or is it better to sit this one out? Let's get into the nitty-gritty to find out, shall we?

AJ Marketing - The Pros and Cons of Influencer Marketing for Brands - Connect

The Pros and Cons of Influencer Marketing for Brands ⬇️

  1. The Basics of Influencer Marketing

  2. Pros of Influencer Marketing

    1. Authenticity and Trust Building

    2. Enhanced Brand Awareness and Reach

    3. Targeting Specific Audiences

    4. High Engagement Rates

    5. Increased Conversion Rates

  3. Cons of Influencer Marketing

    1. Risk of Fake Followers and Low Engagement

    2. Transparency and Credibility Issues

    3. High Costs for Top-tier Influencers

    4. Lack of Control over the Message

    5. Potential for Negative Publicity

  4. Navigating the Influencer Marketing Landscape

1. The Basics of Influencer Marketing

AJ Marketing - The Pros and Cons of Influencer Marketing for Brands - 1

So, what exactly is an influencer? Picture your friendly neighbor, always quick with gardening tips, or maybe that classmate in college who seemed to have an uncanny knack for predicting the coolest hangout spots. Now, give them a digital platform, a sizable audience who hangs on their every word, and a brand willing to partner with them. There you have it—an influencer! They could be a fitness fanatic, a tech whizz, a beauty guru, or just about anyone who can sway their followers' opinions or inspire them to take action.

But don't get it twisted—not all influencers are cut from the same cloth. Some are micro-influencers, beloved for their relatable content and tight-knit community of followers. On the other hand, we have macro-influencers, with follower counts soaring into the hundreds of thousands or even millions. And let's not forget the mega-influencers—your movie stars, your chart-topping musicians, your world-renowned athletes.

They might be different in size and scope, but what they all have in common is a relationship with brands. Whether it's for a one-time promotion or a long-term partnership, these influencers use their platforms to give brands a human face, connecting with audiences on a level traditional advertising often struggles to reach.

2. Pros of Influencer Marketing

AJ Marketing - The Pros and Cons of Influencer Marketing for Brands - 2

Let's delve into the sunny side of things—the many advantages that have placed influencer marketing in the limelight!

A. Authenticity and trust-building

Influencers are like those popular kids in school whose opinion mattered in everything, from fashion to the coolest gadgets. They've won their followers' hearts not just with their charm, but with their authenticity, their openness, and their genuine engagement. People resonate with their content and believe in their recommendations. So, when a brand gets the seal of approval from an influencer, it's like getting an endorsement from a trusted friend.

B. Incredible boost in brand awareness and reach

Remember, influencers are like social media rockstars. When they belt out a tune—or in this case, post about a product—their fans are all ears. They help brands break into the spotlight, extending their scope and boosting brand awareness. And the best part? Influencer marketing hits the bullseye with the hard-to-reach Millennials and Gen Z audience.

C. Target specific audiences with laser-like precision

Think of it as having a sharpshooter on your side. By pairing up with influencers whose followers match your target demographic, you can ensure your message hits the mark every time.

D. High engagement

Influencers command high engagement rates because they've cultivated a loyal fanbase that trusts their recommendations. Their followers aren't just scrolling past posts—they're liking, sharing, and commenting, bringing an abundance of engagement to the table.

E. Increased conversion rates

With influencers already having established trust with their audience, their product recommendations can often lead to a spike in purchases. It's like having a charismatic salesperson who doesn't just sell—they convince!

In a nutshell, influencer marketing has proven itself to be a cost-effective way to amplify brand awareness, captivate new audiences, and escalate engagement and conversion rates. It's all about choosing the right influencers, those whose authenticity and credibility will make your brand shine in the best light possible.

Let's slip in another sweet example to underscore the pros of influencer marketing—Subaru's #MeetAnOwner campaign. They knew they wanted to catch the eye of the millennial buyer, and what better way than to go for an influencer-driven approach. So, they brought in Devin Graham (@devinsupertramp), a YouTube influencer whose subscriber count hovers around an astounding 6 million.

Graham put together a video of him and his friends having the time of their lives with a slip and slide, parachutes, and a 500-foot cliff. Oh, and guess what? The new Subaru Impreza was part of the adventure, showing off in various locations. It wasn't about the nitty-gritty of the car's specs—it was about the experience, the emotion, the excitement of an adventure with friends, and of course, a Subaru.

If you wanna learn from more influencer marketing campaign successes, then check our list of 5 Influencer Marketing Campaigns You Can Learn From.

3. Cons of Influencer Marketing

AJ Marketing - The Pros and Cons of Influencer Marketing for Brands - 3

So we've basked in the glow of influencer marketing's benefits, but let's be real—it's not all sunshine and roses. Just like that chocolate cake that looks oh-so-tempting but can give you a wicked sugar rush, influencer marketing has its own set of cons that brands need to be mindful of:

  1. Risk of Fake Followers and Low Engagement: The digital world isn't immune to fraudsters, and unfortunately, some influencers inflate their follower count with bot followers. It's like hosting a concert with half the crowd being mannequins. Not quite the audience you expect, right? Brands need to ensure they're partnering with influencers who boast genuine followers and solid engagement rates. After all, you want your message to reach actual people, not bots!

  2. Transparency and Credibility Issues: Remember how we value honesty in friendships? It's the same with influencer-brand partnerships. Brands need to be transparent about these collaborations to maintain trust with their audience. No one likes feeling deceived.

  3. High Costs for Top-tier Influencers: Working with celebs or top-tier influencers can leave a gaping hole in your marketing budget, especially for smaller brands.

  4. Lack of Control Over the Message: You can't entirely control what the influencers say about your brand to allow for original and authentic content. If their message doesn't align with your brand's values, well, you're in a pickle.

  5. Potential for Negative Publicity: If an influencer's actions or behavior stirs controversy, your brand could be dragged into the fray too.

A classic case of influencer marketing gone awry is that of Huawei and Egyptian actress Sarah Elshamy. Huawei, known for its high-quality camera phones, hired Elshamy for an ad showing her having a blast while her co-actor snapped selfies on a Huawei phone. However, Elshamy later posted behind-the-scenes photos revealing a DSLR camera being used instead of the Huawei phone. As you can imagine, this drew a storm of criticism on social media, showing just how things can go south if not carefully managed.

4. Navigating the Influencer Marketing Landscape

AJ Marketing - The Pros and Cons of Influencer Marketing for Brands - 4

So, you're ready to dip your toes into the influencer marketing pool. But, where do you start? With the landscape continuously evolving—think trends like the rise of nano-influencers, or the shift towards authenticity and long-term partnerships in 2023—it can be a challenging terrain to navigate. Brands need to stay updated on these latest trends to ensure their influencer marketing strategies are in tune with the times.

Of course, you don't have to venture into this landscape alone. Consider collaborating with an influencer marketing agency. These experts in the field can help identify the right influencers for your brand, negotiate fair rates, and measure the effectiveness of campaigns, making your influencer marketing journey smoother and more rewarding. After all, two heads—or in this case, a brand and an agency—are better than one, right?


As we've seen, influencer marketing is a double-edged sword. Influencer marketing has a lot of pros, but also several cons you might consider. On one side, you have the power to amplify brand awareness, engage specific target audiences, and boost conversion rates, all while giving your brand a human touch. But flip the coin, and you're dealing with potential challenges—fake followers, transparency issues, budget constraints, and the ever-present risk of a message going sideways.

But isn't that the beauty of it? It's a dynamic, evolving landscape that invites brands with its immense potential. Whether you're considering joining the influencer marketing bandwagon or you're already onboard, the key is to stay informed, stay authentic, and perhaps, seek the guidance of an influencer marketing agency.

We wish you luck in navigating this exciting world and finding success in your unique campaigns!

Contact Us

AJ Marketing | Unlock the Power of Influence


bottom of page