top of page

11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid

Let's talk about one of the hottest strategies in today's digital marketing landscape – influencer marketing. You've likely heard the buzz, and it's not without good reason. In 2024, TikTok takes the crown as the reigning champ in the influencer marketing arena. A staggering 40% of marketers said they deem TikTok as a valuable influencer marketing channel, followed closely by Facebook, and YouTube.

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid - Most important marketing platforms 2024

Now, it's no secret that this style of marketing can pack a serious punch when done right. However, like any other marketing strategy, it's not immune to mistakes, pitfalls, and the occasional facepalm moment. And trust us, even the best of us can stumble when navigating this fast-paced world.

So, let's dive right in and explore some common mistakes in influencer marketing. Whether you're a seasoned marketer or a beginner dipping your toes in these waters, we're here to help you avoid these potential pitfalls and get the most out of your campaigns. Buckle up – we've got a lot to cover!

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid - Connect

11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid ⬇️

Mistake 1: Working with the Wrong Influencers

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid - 1

Look, you can't just partner with someone because they're the hottest thing on Instagram right now. Influencer marketing isn't a one-size-fits-all kind of deal. It's like picking out a new pair of sneakers; you need the right fit! Not every influencer is a match made in heaven for your brand.

A confused audience and an unsuccessful campaign. To find the right influencers, consider their audience, the content they create, and if it aligns with your brand's image and values. Do they share your beliefs? Does their audience align with your target market? If the answers are "no," then it's time to swipe left and move on.

Mistake 2: Lacking Support from Your Influencers

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid - 2

Ever tried to build a sandcastle without wet sand? It crumbles, right? The same goes for your relationship with influencers. If they aren't enthusiastic about your brand and really standing behind it, the whole campaign might just crumble. Influencers are like the friends who introduce you to their other friends (a.k.a their followers). If they aren’t genuinely interested and supportive, those friends, i.e., followers, can smell the insincerity a mile away.

Mistake 3: Focusing on Follower Count over Engagement

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid - 3

Imagine hosting the biggest party of the year, but no one's dancing, laughing, or even talking. Awkward, right? That's what it's like to have an influencer with a massive follower count but little to no engagement. It's not about how many people show up to the party, but how many are truly having a good time. The magic of influencer marketing lies in the active, engaged followers–those who comment, share, and really interact with the influencer's content. So, opt for the influencer who's got their audience hanging onto their every post, rather than the one with a ton of silent spectators.

Need proof? Look no further than Gymshark, a fitness apparel brand with a successful influencer marketing campaign tactic. Rather than chasing influencers with the highest follower count, they've built a strong community by working with athletes and influencers who engage deeply with their own communities. By acting as a reflection of the Gymshark brand, these influencers help create a loyal customer base that feels connected to the brand and readily shares their positive experiences. It's not just about numbers; it's about building relationships.

Mistake 4: Overlooking Legalities and FTC Guidelines

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid - 4

Diving into influencer marketing without understanding the legal and Federal Trade Commission (FTC) guidelines is like setting off on a road trip without a map. It's a risky move and could lead to fines or even a damaged brand reputation. The key here is to familiarize yourself with the rules around disclosures and paid promotions. It's a lot easier to plan your route when you have a map in hand.

Mistake 5: Poor Communication with Influencers

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid - 5

Here's something to remember: Good communication isn't just about exchanging messages. It's about making sure you and your influencers are on the same page. Explain your brand's goals and your vision for the campaign. Poor communication can lead to campaigns that don't really click with the audience. But if you and your influencers understand each other and share the same enthusiasm for the campaign, you're likely to see much better results.

Mistake 6: Not Having a Detailed Contract

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid - 6

Rolling out an influencer marketing campaign without a solid contract is like attempting to assemble a puzzle without the picture on the box - it's going to be confusing and frustrating. A comprehensive contract is your essential blueprint, establishing clear terms and expectations for all parties involved.

Here's a handy checklist of what your contract should ideally include:

  1. Campaign Goals: Clearly state the objectives of the collaboration for clarity.

  2. Roles and Responsibilities: Define what exactly is expected from the influencer.

  3. Deliverables: Specify the number and type of posts, stories, videos, etc., required.

  4. Timeline: Include the duration of the campaign and deadlines for deliverables.

  5. Compensation Details: Outline payment terms, whether it's monetary, in-kind, or both.

  6. Content Rights: Define who owns the content created during the campaign and how long they can use it.

  7. Termination Clause: Include the conditions under which the contract can be terminated by either party.

  8. FTC Disclosure Requirement: Remind the influencer of the legal requirement to disclose sponsored content.

Remember, a good contract leaves no room for ambiguity or misunderstandings and sets your campaign up for a smooth execution.

Mistake 7: Not Offering the Right Compensation

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid - 7

Ah, the money talk. It can be awkward, but it's vital to get it right. Your influencers are putting in their time, creativity, and effort to amplify your brand, so it's only fair they receive appropriate compensation. This could be monetary, or it might be product-based, depending on your arrangement.

However, underpaying or undervaluing the influencer's work can lead to a less-than-stellar campaign or even a loss of potential partnerships. Make sure to do your research, understand the market rates, and offer a fair deal that leaves both parties satisfied.

Mistake 8: Not Maintaining Influencer Relationships

Once your campaign is live and kicking, it's easy to sit back and relax. But here's a nugget of wisdom - don't! Influencer marketing isn't a 'one and done' kind of situation. Building and maintaining relationships with your influencers can lead to fruitful, long-term collaborations. Treat your influencers as partners, not just another marketing channel. Keep in touch, provide feedback, and show appreciation. It can make all the difference in fostering a successful and sustainable relationship.

Case in point? Lululemon. This yoga-centric brand has turned the tables on typical influencer partnerships by focusing on smaller influencers and local communities.

Through their Ambassador program, Lululemon builds "authentic relationships" with individuals who are "inspiring leaders, storytellers, and doers from around the world." They don't just drop a product with an influencer and move on. Instead, they engage with them, take their feedback, and even involve them in social impact programs. This has led to engaged communities around their stores and a deeper connection with their influencers. So, remember, don't just build partnerships; nurture them.

Mistake 9: Failing to Track Campaign Performance

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid - 9

You wouldn't drive a car without a dashboard, right? Similarly, running an influencer campaign without tracking its performance is like flying blind. Sure, you're moving, but do you know where you're headed?

It's vital to keep tabs on metrics like engagement rate, conversion rate, or return on investment to evaluate the success of your campaign. Tools like Google Analytics, UTM parameters, or even built-in social media analytics can help measure the effectiveness of your influencer marketing strategy and provide valuable insights for future campaigns.

Mistake 10: Not Diversifying Influencer Portfolio

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid - 10

Think about your investment portfolio. Would you put all your money in one stock? Probably not. The same logic applies to influencer marketing. If you're only working with one type of influencer or sticking to one platform, you're putting all your eggs in one basket.

Expand your reach by diversifying your influencer portfolio. This might mean collaborating with a mix of macro and micro-influencers, or trying out different social media platforms. By diversifying, you increase your chances of connecting with a broader audience and reduce the risk of a campaign falling flat.

Mistake 11: Not Customizing Your Approach for Different Social Media Platforms

AJ Marketing - 11 Worst Mistakes in Influencer Marketing to Avoid - 11

Instagram, TikTok, YouTube... each of these platforms has a unique audience and vibe. So, using the same content across all platforms? Not the best idea. Just like you wouldn't wear a suit to a beach party, you need to tailor your content to fit the platform you're using.

Create platform-specific strategies that appeal to the users of that platform. Maybe that's short, fun videos for TikTok, aesthetic photos for Instagram, or in-depth tutorials for YouTube. Customize your approach, and your audience will thank you for it.


The world of influencer marketing can seem daunting. There are lots of potential pitfalls, and even the most seasoned marketers can make mistakes. But by being mindful of these common errors and making a concerted effort to avoid them, you can set your campaign up for success. Remember, at the heart of every successful influencer marketing strategy is authenticity, clear communication, and solid relationships. Happy marketing!

Contact Us

AJ Marketing | Unlock the Power of Influence


bottom of page